Let's start from the start.
Do you see the customize from the left top, click on it and then select the events also. Now you see the hardware ststus and the received events. Also look at the ES green status on the server. This is the event status for your server. These change if there is an uncleared event. Please add a screenshot of the Events for both servers. If i create a rule that email i also select the option clear event. For test purposes you can use the all events collection to be used for forwardinh. You should get a lot of emails.the collection you choose dictates the events you get emailed. I made an own collection that i want events from. These csn be created by hand.